A Scottish man has been dragged through the courts after police charged him over a “racist” comment he muttered under his breath while being almost run off the road by a reckless driver.
The man, who was driving his four-year-old son home to Glasgow after visiting an amusement park in Falkirk in April last year, was recorded saying “smelly black bastard” on his dashcam seconds after being forced to swerve to avoid colliding with another car.
Fearing the other motorist was drunk, the man called police, who took his dashcam footage to see if an offence had been committed, but returned it the next week and charged him with racially aggravated “threatening or abusive behaviour”.
“How could you charge me for saying it in my car? I was saying it to myself,” the man asked police, as his windows were closed at the time and the other driver could not have heard him.
“The language was still racist,” the policewoman reading him his rights responded.
The man was defended by the Free Speech Union (FSU), and founder Toby Young called described the case as a “near-perfect illustration of anarcho-tyranny … in which law-abiding responsible citizens are persecuted and criminals go unpunished”, in an article for The Spectator.
The driver was ultimately found not guilty, as the prosecution was required to prove that his behaviour was likely to cause fear or alarm, and either intended to or was reckless as to whether it would cause fear or alarm, which the words he said to himself could not have done.
Mr Young described the case as a “colossal waste of everyone’s time”, and pointed out that in Glasgow four out of five burglaries go unsolved.
“In the Yookay, though, trying to bring criminals to justice is far more likely to get you into trouble than breaking the law,” he wrote.






















