We notice what other news sites don’t

Australia - Opinion

OPINION

How One Nation saved the Liberal Party

Roy Morgan just dropped a poll showing the Liberal/National Coalition ahead federally, both on primary vote and a two-party preferred basis, for the first time since the 2025 federal election.

The Liberals seemed dead and buried earlier this year, with leading pollsters projecting them to win less than 10 seats and effectively be reduced to minor party status if an election was held then, so how the hell have they recovered?

Answering this question correctly is probably the most important diagnostic for the Australian right to get right, right now.

The Liberal Party is not going to end mass immigration. The Liberal Party is not going to restore free speech. The Liberal Party has three masters: property developers, property investors and the Jewish Lobby – and if it takes power that is who it will rule for – which means more mass immigration and hate speech laws.

This is why the activist right tried to kill the Liberal Party last year in its moment of weakness. And why we celebrated their election defeat and cheered on their demise.

We were clearly right that Australian politics was ripe for realignment.

Unfortunately, our efforts to delegitimise the Liberals and force a debate on mass immigration to the forefront of the national conversation opened up political space to the exclusive benefit of One Nation. As thanks to the Liberals, everything to their right was banned.

One Nation were the beneficiaries of the immigration debate being forced by the activist right, but they weren’t the cause. One Nation is effectively being run to convert anti-immigration sentiment into revenue, not power.

This is why they had no organised branch structure of activists and campaigners and complete incoherence on policy. They weren’t anticipating becoming so popular that they even needed detailed policies, and they weren’t planning on actually competing to form government.

All One Nation existed to do was voice (often poorly articulated) complaints about mass immigration and woke BS, and by virtue of their legacy brand recognition suffocate the space to the right of the Liberal Party with indolence and passivity. Whether this was a literal “op” by the Liberals to control their flank, or simply a consequence of Hanson’s lack of vision or initiative, for the past decade this is the structural role One Nation has played in Australian politics.

However, with anti-immigration sentiments boiling over in response to the Albanese government opening the floodgates like never before in Australian history, and the Liberals fumbling the 2025 election campaign by failing to oppose them on it – One Nation was set up to surge.

Then the Liberals completely misinterpreted why they lost, [elected moderate girlboss Sussan Ley as their leader and focused on courting the “multicultural vote” while the activist right plotted nationwide March For Australia anti-immigration rallies.

By the beginning of 2026, One Nation had spectacularly surpassed the Coalition in the polls with the immigration debate animating the electorate. Polling showed over a third of 2025 Liberal voters were changing allegiances to One Nation, but also that almost a fifth of 2025 Labor voters had also defected – turns out that courting White Labor voters with immigration restriction was a better strategy than trying to win over Asian Labor voters with tax cuts.

But the Liberals reacted. They replaced the disastrous Sussan Ley with the straight-talking Angus Taylor, his mentor Tony Abbott then installed himself as president. And then after the mess One Nation made of communicating their revised immigration policy, they came in with a comparable plan to reduce immigration to late-90s levels.

2026 started off well for One Nation, they had the support of a broad base who saw them as a battering ram to punish and break the uniparty, and were flying high in the polls. The populist edge has been taken off them under heightened scrutiny, however. Hanson’s strategically retarded statements on cutting parental leave and making it easier to sack workers, as well as associations with various other unpopular positions on abortion, Israel and the Iran war began to take the shine off One Nation.

Meanwhile, the Liberals have been sitting on the sidelines, out of sight and out of mind. Letting voters forget about their past treachery, focusing their rage at the Labor government over inflation, taxes, and their despicable censorship agenda. The right-wing press has formulated a narrative of discontent that plays to traditional Liberal strengths on economic management, whilst One Nation’s ineptitude at formulating a narrative with voter resonance of its own beyond tapping into general anti-immigration sentiment has been exposed.

One Nation, it turns out, wasn’t a battering ram against the uniparty, but a battering ram against Labor that feeds preferences back into the Coalition. With the Liberals matching One Nation largely on policy, but mogging them on competence, voters are now turning back to the “safe” option of conservative government reminiscent of Howard and Abbott.

If One Nation actually wants to win the next federal election, they need to re-establish brand differentiation from the Liberal Party. Especially (but not only) on immigration.

This will require something different than just cutting the numbers further. Most voters want immigration cut, but only a minority support a net-negative immigration program, and the pop has already been taken out of further numerical revisions by the policy announcements of the past few months.

Something radically different from what’s already been said needs to be proposed on immigration. Something the Liberals won’t match. Something which is even more popular than what’s already being proposed. Something which will excite the base and reanimate the debate.

The only new policy on immigration which meets all of these requirements would be a commitment to prioritise migrants from Western countries over non-Western visa applicants. To actively pursue migration primarily from Europe rather than Asia again.

This is not the first time I have proposed this, I wrote a whole article on it after One Nation announced its policy back in September. A key statistic which I mentioned to support this proposal, is that prioritising migrants from “countries that share our values such as the UK, Canada and New Zealand” is more than twice as popular with voters as net-zero and net-negative migration combined, according to the IPA’s March Immigration Poll.

68% of voters in the study supported such a policy, and only 13% opposed it. 72% of Coalition voters supported it. 54% of Labor voters supported it.

If One Nation starts this debate, it will win it, and everyone else will lose it. Australians far prefer migrants from Europe to migrants from anywhere else, which is demonstrated clearly by the Scanlon Social Cohesion study. Where the migrants come from, and whether they are culturally compatible and will assimilate or not (these are largely proxy categories for being White), matters more to people than simply how many as a raw number.

One Nation should not fear being attacked as “racist” for adopting a policy like this, it will literally only make them more popular again. It will reanimate them with anti-establishment aura and reignite the base to rally around them once more. GetUp! strategists have literally told their campaigners to stop calling Hanson a racist because it makes voters like her more, not less.

One Nation also needs to recognise that their anti-establishment brand is rooted in opposition to not simply Labor, but the Coalition as well. They need to attack them both. Calling out the Liberals as complicit in Labor’s anti-free speech agenda is critical in this regard – when One Nation did this after the Liberals backed Labor’s hate group laws in January, they only gained in the polls from it at the Liberal’s expense.

Free speech might not be the most salient issue in itself, but it is a principle most voters support – and if fit into a broader narrative about a multicultural police state that prioritises repressing political opposition over policing out-of-control (migrant-fuelled) street crime, it can become a potent basis to bring together various themes that draw voters to One Nation.

One Nation’s failure to make the repeal of Victoria’s egregiously bad “vilification” laws a policy for the state election there this month will cost them seats in close races, where their campaign could have been bolstered by a motivated activist base. I warned them about this, and their base marched to show them where they stood, but they didn’t listen. As a result, the activist base down there that would otherwise be campaigning for them, isn’t.

If you don’t care about what your base tells you it cares about, they stop caring about you – ask Trump how this works out. They should rectify this for the NSW election – if they put Minns and his multicultural police state on the backfoot it will pay off.

I have been saying this stuff for months now though, as have prominent commentators such as Hugo Lennon, yet they won’t listen to us. Polling earlier this year showed more than half the country is open to voting for One Nation – they hit a ceiling of their own making, they are capable of more.

Maybe they need to see the momentum that we created for them really die out for them to start listening. Or maybe they just want to save the Liberals after all.

Header image: Pauline Hanson and Tony Abbott (Facebook).

If you like what we do, please consider making a regular donation via PayPal below, or with cryptocurrency on the Support Us page:

SUBSCRIBE TO THE NOTICER

Get all of our articles direct to your inbox daily

latest Articles

Popular Opinion

The Noticer

FACTUAL NEWS, UNCENSORED VIEWS

For submissions and tips, or to advertise with us: 

editor@noticer.news

SUPPORT US

If you like what we do, please consider making a regular donation with the button below, or with cryptocurrency on the Support Us page:

With your generosity we can cover more stories that are ignored, minimised or misrepresented by the corporate media, reduce the ads, and stay independent.

Check out independent news aggregator Europa.com

ANALYSIS

Buy Anglophobia using our Amazon affiliate link above to support the British Australian Community and The Noticer

Media Shame File
ART & CULTURE
SCIENCE

SUBSCRIBE TO THE NOTICER

Get all of our articles direct to your inbox daily