A homosexual paedophile teacher has been spared jail by a Victorian judge despite being caught with child abuse images of young boys and fantasising about sex with children in online chats.
Michael James Carty, 36, who previously worked for La Trobe University and St Joseph’s College Mildura, pleaded guilty earlier this month to using a carriage service to transmit child abuse material and possessing and controlling child abuse material.
He appeared in the County Court on Monday where Judge Fiona Todd sentenced him to five months’ imprisonment, but found exceptional circumstances and gave him a recognizance release order so he could avoid jail, The Herald Sun reported.
Carty was immediately released, and is required to be under corrections supervision for 18 months, undergo sex offender treatment, and report changes in living arrangements.
He was also placed on the sex offenders register with reporting obligations for 15 years, and ordered to pay $1,000.
Judge Todd said that if Carty had not pleaded guilty she would have sentenced him to 18 months’ imprisonment, with release under a recognizance order after nine months.
The court heard Carty had an agreement with his partner that they could have sexual conversations with other men online, and in May 2024 discussed sexual fantasies involving children with a user named Paul on WhatsApp.
When police searched his devices they found child abuse images of boys on a hard drive and an iPhone 7, and Carty told police that although he felt “disgusted” by the conversations he would “get himself off” afterwards.
He was charged on February 11 this year and granted bail.
At a previous hearing Carty’s lawyer told her client was “suffering” as a result of being charged, was in tears during the police raid of his home, and had been given 15 character references, including from his high school English teacher.
Carty worked at St Joseph’s College Mildura between July 2022 and June 2025, worked as a senior coordinator for education partnerships and a casual academic at La Trobe, and featured as La Trobe University Student Ambassador in local media.
Header image: Michael Carty (La Trobe University).





















