An Afghan-born Muslim senator has asked why the Australian Army needs tanks if it hasn’t used them in combat since the Vietnam War, and said they should be replaced with simulators to save money.
Hijab-wearing Independent senator Fatima Payman, who is a dual citizen, raised the issue in Senate Estimates on Thursday, where she asked how much the Australian Defence Force spent on its 75 M1A2 Abrams main battle tanks, and later shared a clip of the exchange on social media.
When she was told the program cost $1.8 billion, which was later clarified to be $1.2 billion for the tanks alone, she asked how Defence could justify purchasing the tanks when they have “only been used for training purposes” for the past 50 years, and buying 75 simulators would cost just $280 million.
“Senator, what I can tell you is that we have a range of capabilities in the Australian Defence Force, which are prudent for our ability to fight and win Australia’s wars, and through government direction and decision tanks are a part of that capability,” Chief of Army Susan Coyle replied.
“They’re an important part of our capability of the Australian Army, in order for us to be able to fight and win the land combat battle. They are an incredibly potent part of our capability, and they also form part of our deterrence.”
“$1.8 billion is a lot of money,” Ms Payman said, and Ms Coyle responded, “it’s a lot of armour, Senator”.
Tanks but…no tanks. https://t.co/2by01p9u1Y
— Fatima Payman (@SenatorPayman) October 29, 2026
“So, what wars are we hoping to win?” Ms Payman asked.
“So the predominant strategy as set out in the National Defence Strategy is one of strategic denial, and deterrence, we are hoping, and posturing, and working with partners to not have to fight a war, but the most potent methods of having deterrence is to have capability, so your adversaries think twice before they engage in armed combat,” replied Secretary of the Department of Defence Meghan Quinn, who earns a taxpayer-funded salary package of $1.02 million per year.
“So we bought these tanks to win wars, but we haven’t used a tank in a war in 50 years,” Ms Payman said, and when Ms Quinn said that equipment was not bought in the hope of using it, Ms Payman again stated that $1.8 billion “is a lot of money”.
“That’s over a long period of time, but we invest in capability to defend Australia, and to protect our national interest, which is intended to not have a war,” Ms Quinn replied.
Header image: Left, Ms Payman. Right, Ms Coyle (Parliament of Australia).





















